Mindful Eye Logo

Cutler Bay, FL

44,750 residents•6,286 students•19 schools
Avg School Rating
7.7
out of 10
28% above Florida avg
Test Proficiency
66%Math
64%Reading
13% above Florida avg
School Crime Rate
0.32
per 1,000 students
72% below Florida avg
Overall Crime Rate
23.64
per 1,000 residents
26% below Florida avg

School Breakdown

Elementary Schools
13
Elementary Schools
Middle Schools
4
Middle Schools
High Schools
2
High Schools

School Types

By Type

Public
7
Charter
3
Private
9

By Level

Elementary
13
Middle
4
High
2

These figures describe every school in Cutler Bay; use the filters below to explore the directory.

Schools in Cutler Bay

19 schools
9.9
Mater Academy Bay Middle School
Middlecharter
9.5
Mater High South
Highcharter
9.3
Mater Academy Bay Elementary
Elementarycharter
8.7
Cutler Bay Senior High School
Highpublic
6.9
Dr. Edward L. Whigham Elementary School
Elementarypublic
6.5
Cutler Ridge Elementary School
Elementarypublic
6.4
Gulfstream Elementary School
Elementarypublic
6.0
Bel-Aire Elementary School
Elementarypublic
5.7
Cutler Bay Middle
Middlepublic
—
Boystown
Elementarypublic
—
Career Prep Academy of South
Middleprivate
—
Cutler Ridge Christian Academy
Elementaryprivate

School Crime in Cutler Bay

2 incidents reported at K-12 schools across Cutler Bay in 2024 — city-wide, not specific to any one school.

School Crime Rate
72% below Florida avg
0.32
per 1,000 students

School Offense Breakdown

Violent
1
Property
1

School Crime Types

  • Sex50%
  • Vandalism50%

School Crime Rate is per 1,000 students enrolled. Source: FBI NIBRS 2024. Figures are city-wide; NIBRS does not report the specific school or address.

Overall Crime in Cutler Bay

1,058 total incidents reported across Cutler Bay in 2024 — all locations, city-wide.

Overall Crime Rate
26% below Florida avg
23.64
per 1,000 residents

Offense Breakdown

Violent
241
Property
782
Drug
27
Weapons
5
Other
3

Crime Types

  • Theft47%
  • Assault19%
  • Fraud10%
  • Vandalism7%
  • Vehicle Theft6%
  • Drugs3%
  • Other8%

Overall Crime Rate is per 1,000 residents. Source: FBI NIBRS 2024. City-wide totals across all reported incidents and locations.

Enrollment by School Type

6,286 students enrolled across Cutler Bay's schools.

  • Public3,35153%
  • Charter1,96231%
  • Private97315%

Counts students at schools that report enrollment to NCES (about 9 in 10 schools across every sector, including private). Schools with no reported enrollment are excluded. Source: NCES.

Student Demographics

Enrollment-weighted across Cutler Bay's K-12 schools.

  • Hispanic77%
  • Black25%
  • White9%
  • Two or More Races2%
  • Asian1%
  • Native American<1%
46%Female54%Male
9%Free/Reduced Lunch
Sources: FBI NIBRS 2024 (crime) · U.S. Census Bureau 2025 (population) · NCES (schools).Crime figures are city-wide and not specific to any individual school.